Anonymous asked:
I need to thank you for opening my eyes to something as well as showcase reading a point of view matters, even if one doesn't realize it. The Stiles as the main character stories has flooded ao3 so much that when I started my own W.I.P I didn't even question the elimination of Scott. And even when I added him I didn't question my dismissal of him as important. Becoming a member of the Scott defense squad I see now that that is a very bad way to go. Even if the focus gets sift to Stiles as a main character it does not take away the fact that the main character is the main character and has importance. And unfortunately a trinkle down effect of reading so many stories that tell a particular story It causes the readers to have a mindset of what a character is like even if they don't realize why that character was written that way in the original piece that portrayed him that way. And even worse when they don't take in the source material it paints a picture that doesn't showcase the character in the best light. Even though I saw the source material and loved it It did not stop me from going down this route because of everything that I had read. So again I thank you, and the rest of the defense squad for opening my eyes.
princeescaluswords:
Let me make things perfectly clear: there is absolutely nothing wrong with writing a Stiles-centric story. There are no ships involving Stiles that should not be written or explored. My involvement with End Racism on the OTW isn’t because Stiles will never be my favorite character. It’s because there is a vast majority of people who claim to be Stiles fans, Derek fans, Sterek fans, Steter fans, or fans of any other ship which involves white characters who are not actually motivated by those characters but instead by racist fury because Teen Wolf never pretended to be anything other than a story about a Latino teenager.
It’s not about one story. It’s about all of them together. It’s about the fact that the OTW’s policies for AO3 aid and abet a large part of my fandom to indulge in racist fantasies without regard to the parts of the fandom damaged by it, and they do so by hiding behind a screen of polite indifference and pearl-clutching about freedom. And from everything I’ve read and seen, it’s not just my fandom.
Teen Wolf is simply the fandom in which I witnessed it. Look at that picture up there from Night School (1x07). It’s a pretty classic horror shot, no? Now think of the majority of stories on AO3 where
- Peter’s murder sprees and selfishness are excused because of the fire.
- Derek’s terrible decision making and massive trust issues are excused because of what Kate Argent did to him.
- Stiles’s lies and outbursts are excused because of his mother’s death and the nogitsune.
- Isaac’s brutality and indifference are excused because of his treatment by his father.
- Yet, Scott is dismissed as ‘whiny’ and 'ungrateful’ because he didn’t immediately see being a werewolf as a positive thing. There was an untagged story yesterday which has Stiles wishing Scott would get his head out of ass and realize all that being a werewolf had done to him was cure his asthma, get a girlfriend and make first line.
What’s the difference between these five characters? This isn’t one story, or ten stories, or a hundred stories, but literally thousands of stories that contain these tropes.
- Hey, remember when Peter literally beat Derek into submission and savaged Lydia to get Stiles to cooperate?
- Remember when Derek tried to murder Lydia for something she didn’t do and drive Isaac away by throwing glass at his head?
- Remember when Talia Hale covered up her brother’s and son’s involvement in the death of a young girl and badgered a woman to carry her child to term?
- Remember when Scott told Stiles that it was wrong to kill the victim of a mad scientist’s experiments and lying about it and maybe he should go talk to his dad?
And yet, I can guarantee you that there is only one of those four alphas who is portrayed consistently as an obtuse tyrant. (Hint: it’s not the white ones) And this isn’t one story, or ten stories, or a hundred stories, but literally thousands of stories that contain these tropes.
And it’s not just the lead. Let’s take a look at how the fandom treats secondary characters on AO3:
- Talia Hale (1 episode): 5190 stories
- Laura Hale (2 episodes): 8760 stories
- Jenna Geyer (mentioned once; name is fandom generated): 617
- Claudia Stilinski (1 episode; impersonated for 8 episodes): 3079
- Derek Hale’s Father (never appeared or mentioned): 843
- Noshiko Yukimura (16 episodes): 470
- Ken Yukimura (20 episodes): 261
- Satomi Ito (3 episodes): 284
- David Geyer (5 episodes): 351
See a pattern? You should. As I said, it’s not one story, it’s thousands.
No one’s saying that you or anyone else shouldn’t write fictions that focus on Stiles or Sterek or even stories where Scott is a terrible person. It’s the trends. If transformation is what AO3 and OTW tout as their purpose, and that transformation is about variety and exploration, why is it always the white characters that get the benefit of it? When it comes to transformation, why do characters of color get erased, caricatured, or robbed of their narrative roles?
Don’t tell me that it isn’t damaging.
Do you know how many times I’ve encountered a person who entered Teen Wolf fandom through AO3 and Tumblr who believed that the characters of color are either terrible (such as Scott and Deaton and Braeden) or unimportant (such as Boyd or Mason or the Yukimuras)? More than I or anyone else should be comfortable with. But this is part of the mechanism. There aren’t little racism fairies that visit people in their sleep; it’s not a bacterial infection; it’s not the work of a secret cabal. Cultural racism is maintained by institutions, and it is transmitted by institutions, and this is one example. OTW and AO3 are two such institutions.
Thanks for writing. I’ll take what you told me as a compliment.